Thursday, November 20, 2008

Shiloh Student Response

Look at a friend's post in Shiloh Chapter 4-7. I want you to post a response about what they wrote. Describe how you agree with them, how you disagree with them, and any other comments you have about the reading or their post. Example:

Dear Paul,
I read your post and thought _________.
When you wrote________ I agreed with you because ____________.
When youo wrote________I disagreed with you because __________.
I also thought it was interseting that you _____________.
Your Classmate,
Stephen

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Dear,Luis.I read you Comments, I think.
I read your comment i think it was okay.
I agreed when you said if you lie it will efeect you in the future.
It will efeect you.
I never disagreed with you because your comments are ok.
that you said Dara -Lynn always wants to go up the hill were Shiloh is.
**classmate ,**Lizbet**

Anonymous said...

Dear Lizbet,

i read your post i thought it was really good. when you wrote what Shiloh said to Marty (i want to stay whith you not that mean Judd Traves.)i agreed whith you because Judd should not abuse no dogs. i do not diagree whith none of your comments because they were all great.i also agread whith you when you said it is not okay to abuse anyone if you been abused.

your classmate, Luis

Anonymous said...

Dear Lauren

I read your post and thought in every coment you thght its all Judds fault.When you wrote "no its not okay for Judd to obused his dogs and should know how it feels" I dont agree with Judd shuold know how it feels because Judd already knoo how it feels because he got obused when he was little.

Anonymous said...

Dear Christian,

I read your post and I agree with you with #1. I also said that lying is only good for a good cost.I also agree with you with #2.Marty is doing the right thing.I said something like that for #3. I don't agree with you with #4.VIOLENCE is NOT the way to solve problems.

Anonymous said...

Dear Janee,
I read your post and thought it was very good and worded good but sometimes strange and confusing.When you wrote that lying was never ok unless it was an emergency I agreed with you because that is what you sould do in life.When you wrote that Shiloh would thank Marty for keeping him a secret I disagreed with you because most dogs like for people to love them and like to be outside. I also thought it was interesting that you and I thought that Judd Travers should have been a better person since he got a abused by his father.

Anonymous said...

Dear Peri,
I read your post and thought it was very interesting.When you wrote it's okay to lie depending on the problem I toatly agreed with you.When you wrote that just because Judd was abused as a kid he has to abuse his dog because It dosnt mean hes mean because he was abused.I also thought it was interesting that you would what shiloh would have said
From,
Rachel

Anonymous said...

DearRachel,
I read your post and I thought it was very amusing and interesting.When you wrote Judd should not abuse Shiloh i agree with you becauce it is just plan rong.When you wrote about lieing i disagre with you because not only problems.I also thought it was interesting that you said Shiloh would DIE!
Your classmate,
Peri(HI)

Anonymous said...

Dear Samantha,

I read your post and thought that it was very good. When you wrote that it was ok for Marty to lie in that siuation I had to agree whith you. When you wrote thigs I laughed! I also thought it was interesting that you said he was making it worse.
your classmate,
Janee

Anonymous said...

Dear,dontoh and george, i read your post and thought it was good when you wrote it is not ok for judd to miss treat his pets i agreed with you.

Anonymous said...

Dear Vanessa
3.We think it also ok to lie sometimes because it might save someone from abuse.
2.I agree it is also ok for Marty to lie because he is helping Shiloh.
3.I dissagree when you said thanking you for tacking me.
4.It was interesting when tyou said it is not ok to abuse your dogs.