1. Is it ever OK for people to lie?
2. Is Marty doing the right thing by lying, or is he making things worse?
3. If Shiloh could talk, what would he tell Marty?
4. If SHiloh could talk, what would he tell Judd?
5. Is it OK for Judd to abuse his dogs because he was aboused by his father? Why or why not?
If there is time, read someone a friend's post and respond to them (I also agree because... No, I don't agree because...) and post it in Shiloh Student Response.
10 comments:
1.Only when it`s okay to lie for a good cause.
2.He is doing both because he is helping Shiloh get away from Judd Travers.And he lies than after a little lie there is always another lie that accouring.
3.He will tell Marty (i want to stay with you not with the mean Judd Travers.
4.If he could talk he will tell Judd travers (I will run away and never come back because you abuse dogs).
5. It is never okay to abuse dogs just because you were abused by your father and when you think about that you will be sorry.
1.No it is not good for people to lie because it will effect them later in the future.
2. I think Marty is doing the right thing because he is helping a dog that gets abused by Judd Traveres. I think things are getting worser because, every day Dara Lynn wants to go on the hill every day were Shilo is.
3.If Shilo could talk he would say thank you for being so kind to me and not abusing like that mean Judd Traves.
4.If Shiloh could talk he would tell Judd Traves why are you abusing me i`ve never did anything wrong to you.
5.No it is not nice for Judd to abuse Shiloh, because if hes been abused he should know how Shiloh feels when he abuses Shiloh.
1. I think that lying it's O.K to lie somtimes dependign on the problem.
2.He is doing a good thing by keeping Shiloh a secrat because if Judd found out Shiloh he would proububly be dead.
3.He would tell Marty that he is happy that he toke him to a better place then Judds house.
4.If shiloh could talk to Judd he would say he felt very bad and just because he was abused as a kid he dosn't have to abuse he's dogs.
5. It is not okay for Judd to abuse his dog because he dosnt like it and because he was abused.
1.I think that it is ok to lie only when it might come to problem.
2.I think Marty can lie because it is for the safty of shiloh.
3.If Shiloh could talk I think he would tell Marty that he would say thank you for taking good care of me.
4.If shiloh could talk he would tell Judd he is the most harable person ever and you will never hert me ever agen.
5.No it is not nessary for Judd to hert Shiloh just because his father hert him so he should not be like his father and not hert Shiloh.
1.I think that is okay to lie but has to be for the right reason like in Marty Preston's siuation. He has a dog he is lying about to keep him safe that could get him into deep trouble
2.I think lying would not be the best thing but he has to in order to keep Shiloh safe. Marty is making thigs worse for himself.
3.If Shiloh could talk to Marty he would say I am very thankful that you are taking me in and for feeding me.
4.If Shiloh could talk to Judd Travers he would say you were very disrespectful to me.You need to learn how to treat me and I will never go back to you.
5.It is not okay to let Judd Travers abuse his dogs because he got abuse by his father that should actually help him.
1. I think that lieing is never ok unless it is emergency.
2. I think Marty is making things worse for himself.
3. I think Shiloh will thank Marty for keeping him a secret and for feeding him.
4. I think if Shiloh could speak to Judd I never appreciated what you do to me.
5. It is not ok for anybody to abuse any dog even though there father abused him. If I where in that situation I would try not to be like my father!!
1. It is not okay for someone to lie unless a life is at stake.
2.I think Marty is doing the right thing by lying to Judd about Shiloh.
3.If Shiloh could talk, he would say "I love you and i'm glad you cared for me!"
4. If Shiloh could talk, he would tell Judd "Why did you abuse me, starve me,and disrespect me?"
5. Not is not okay for Judd to abuse Shiloh and Judd shouldknow how it feels.
1.No it is not ok for someone to but only if your lying for a good thing.
2.Marty is doing the right thing to lie because hes tring to save shiloh so he cuold not get obused and so Shiloh could live happier.
3.If Shiloh could talk he would say to Marty thankyou so much for feeding me and saving me from that mean guy Judd Travers.
4.If Shiloh could talk he would say to Judd Travers WOW!You are such a bad owner who would hert thier dog.You are so lucky that I dont nock the bicuits out of you.
5.NO! It is not okay for Judd to obused an animal just because his dad obused him.No because animals aren't that powerful as peaple.
1. It is not ok to lie unless it is about a good thing.
1.Yes it okay to lie if your trying to help someone.
2.Marty is kind of making things worse but he is making things better for Shiloh.
2.He is making better for Shiloh by lying to make sure he is feed and making it worse by making his family look bad.
3.If Shiloh could talk he would probably tell Marty that he is so happy that he rescued him from Judd Travers.
3.If Shiloh could talk he would tell Marty hes the best owner he could have.4.I think he would tell Judd he is so lucky he can not get up and knock the living daylights out of him!
5.If Shiloh could talk he would tell Judd he is the worst dog owner a dog could have!!
5.No it is not ok for judd to miss treat his pets just for how he got treaten.
No its not ok to abuse his pets because he got abused.
1.i think it is sometimes ok to lie for a good reason.
2.I think marty is doing the right by lying because he is helping shiloh
3.i think if shiloh could talk he would tell marty thank you for tacking me.
4.if shiloh could talk i think he would say you are a bad owner
5.no it is not ok to abuse your dog because you got abused.
Post a Comment